I forced myself to not to eat more than one slice of the warm bread and seasoned butter before my entree. That took major willpower. I had the cajun popcorn shrimp caesar salad minus the cheese with the dressing on the side. I must not have minded that it packed a little punch because I nearly cleaned the plate. The key lime pie was made fresh by Kevin, our friendly waiter. I'm a key lime pie connoisseur and I have to say this was real key lime pie. It was ridiculous i.e. good as heyl, key lime pie... Okay I'm off the key lime pie soapbox.
But don't just go there for the zesty food and wine. The staff is efficient and attentive. Donny Syracuse, the charming former rock band member and owner will greet you with a warm smile and make sure you're enjoying your meal. Dave Manley, acoustic jazz guitarist, will play some creative interpretations of familiar and not so familiar melodies that will make your experience as lively as your tastebuds.
Call for reservations, especially on the weekend. It gets packed.
The High Street Caffe
322 S. High Street
West Chester PA 19382
610-696-7435